The Disappointment of Oshi no Ko: Ambitious Themes Undermined by Narrative Flaws

The discourse surrounding Oshi no Ko has stirred significant debate among anime enthusiasts, as many viewers express dissatisfaction with its narrative structure and conclusions. This anime, while ambitious, appears to falter under the weight of its own aspirations. Below, the intricacies of the series are explored, revealing both its commendable ideas and the shortcomings that ultimately mar its execution.

Oshi no Ko has garnered controversy due to numerous discrepancies within its plot. The storyline seems to lack cohesive thought throughout its progression, leaving viewers confused about the roles of elements like Tsukuyomi and Crow Girl. However, the most significant letdown comes from the unsatisfactory ending.

The series boasted numerous captivating plotlines with the potential to lead to remarkable developments. Despite being a thriller, the execution felt shallow, as the supernatural aspects failed to produce any real excitement. The character of Crow Girl appeared primarily as a vehicle for the supernatural theme, lacking a substantial role in the narrative. Following the manga’s conclusion, fans expressed disappointment at the feeling of a hurried wrap-up.

The allure of Oshi no Ko stemmed from its unique portrayal of the idol industry and the darker realities faced by these figures. The portrayal of idols being pursued by obsessive fans is a chilling reflection of real-world issues. The storyline involving Ai Hoshino had the potential to resonate deeply, given its themes of reincarnation and mystery, which kept viewers intrigued. Nonetheless, many other plot elements ultimately fell flat, failing to realize their potential impact.

Upon the series' conclusion, fans began to reflect on a major flaw: the supernatural elements that became obtrusive rather than enhancing. Crow Girl had the capability to significantly affect the resurrection of Gorou and Sarina portray Aqua and Ruby, yet this was never established. Instead, her character wandered aimlessly between hope and manipulation regarding the twins' lives.

The narrative might have benefited from focusing solely on reincarnation within its supernatural framework. Many suggest that the author may have added Crow Girl without a clear intention, leading to a disjointed narrative. Her presence could have furthered Aqua’s quest for revenge against Hikaru, though she ultimately appeared ineffective in preventing dire outcomes.

Aqua's actions against Hikaru took him to a bleak place that might have been avoided with proper emotional support and a sense of healing. While Hikaru's misdeeds warranted consequences, the manner of the young Hoshino's abrupt demise felt illogical. The emotions expressed by Kana and Ruby were profound and heartfelt.

Both twins deserved richer conclusions, yet when a narrative unfolds under the guidance of Aka Akasaka, a rushed ending seems to be the inevitable result. Fans concur that the author struggles with effectively intertwining plotlines, a trend also noted in previous works.

Oshi no Ko can be viewed on Crunchyroll.