Navigating the Chaos: A Review of the Deck of Many Things Supplement Pack for Dungeons & Dragons

  • Maria Bianchi
  • May-23-2024
Navigating the Chaos: A Review of the Deck of Many Things Supplement Pack for Dungeons & Dragons

In the vast, imaginative worlds of Dungeons & Dragons (D&D), the inclusion of mythical artifacts often serves to enrich the narrative, adding layers of unpredictability and grandiose moments that players will talk about for years to come. Yet, there is one artifact that has historically been met with a blend of awe and trepidation by Dungeon Masters (DMs) the world over: The Deck of Many Things. This review delves into the recently released supplement pack centered around this infamous artifact, aiming to explore whether its revisions bring it out of the realm of feared campaign-ruiners and into a more harmonious existence with the carefully laid plans of dungeon masters everywhere.

Architectural Overview

Dungeons & Dragons red dragon

At its core, The Deck of Many Things is a D&D artifact known for its unparalleled capacity to introduce randomness into the game. Drawing a card from the deck could have dire consequences or shower the player in unimaginable rewards, making it a tool of gamble that many DMs hesitate to introduce into their campaigns. This supplement pack by Wizards of the Coast attempts to tame this chaos, packaging it in a way that aims to appeal more to the side of chaotic good rather than chaotic evil.

Contents Unveiled

The supplement itself is a hefty offering, consisting of two books and a 66-card deck encased in a dedicated storage box. The deck, an expanded iteration of the original concept, boasts impressive artwork albeit with a feel of fragility. Where the original deck was content with 22 cards, this expanded set seeks to provide a richer tapestry for storytelling - though the actual execution of its aesthetic leaves something to be desired when compared to more thematic sets like the Tarroka deck from Curse of Strahd.

The Guide

Accompanying the physical deck is the Card Reference Guide, a resource aimed at helping DMs integrate the deck into their game with randomized events and outcomes. While the guide leans heavily on visual aids, it serves as a crucial navigator for DMs looking to use the deck as more than just an extreme chaos agent within their narrative.

The Tome

“The Book of Many Things” is the cornerstone of this supplement, offering DMs a plethora of ways to use the cards. From generating adventures to introducing new spells, locations, and NPCs, the book attempts to weave the chaos of the deck into something that can be planned around, or at least anticipated. The new additions are intriguing, but the real test comes in integrating these elements into a campaign without overwhelming it.

Gameplay Implications

Dungeons & Dragons art

The true measure of any D&D supplement is how it plays out in an actual campaign. The Deck of Many Things presents both an opportunity and a challenge in this regard. Its integration into existing campaigns is fraught with potential pitfalls, potentially upsetting the narrative balance that DMs work so hard to maintain. However, for those building campaigns from the ground up, the supplement offers a treasure trove of ideas that can add depth and unpredictability to the adventure in controlled, intentional ways.

Purchasing Perspectives

The decision to purchase The Deck of Many Things is not straightforward. Its utility and worth are heavily dependent on the DM’s ability to integrate its chaotic elements into their campaign without derailment. Additionally, the financial investment is significant, raising questions about its value compared to other supplements. In a landscape filled with expansion packs and supplemental materials, The Deck of Many Things occupies a unique space. Its allure is undeniable, but its practical application is niche, suited more for those willing to weave its randomness into the fabric of their storytelling from the onset, rather than attempting to retrofit it into established narratives.


In sum, The Deck of Many Things supplement pack is a bold attempt to reframe one of D&D’s most notorious artifacts into a more manageable, although still unpredictable, campaign element. Its success in this endeavor is mixed, offering a wealth of creative potential that is somewhat hampered by practical challenges in implementation. With a steep price point and specific utility, it’s a purchase best considered by DMs ready to embrace the chaos, with the patience and creativity to make it work within their worlds.